The lower half of its pointed arch is buried under centuries of accumulated ground, and the chamfered stone surround, cut at a careful angle to shed rainwater, now frames a view of grass rather than the interior of Matehy parish church. The east gable has vanished entirely, and the west gable leans at an angle that may not be its original one, having been patched and adjusted at some unknown point. What survives is the rough outline of a building, ivy-covered north and south walls running about fifteen metres, and a small Latin cross, roughly shaped and barely knee-height, embedded at the foot of the west wall.

The church was already struggling by the early seventeenth century. A record from 1615 describes it as being only in partial repair, which suggests a building that had been neglected rather than actively maintained. By 1774, it was in ruins. Somewhere in that century and a half, the east gable came down and the interior of the south wall was heavily rebuilt, though whether by design or necessity is not clear. A headstone in the north-west corner, dated 1779, shows that the graveyard remained in use even as the church itself fell apart around it, which was not unusual in post-Reformation Ireland, where many medieval parish churches were abandoned or left to decay while burials continued in the surrounding ground. The small Latin cross pressed into the earth near the west wall is harder to date and harder to explain; it may be a grave marker or a boundary stone, its rough shaping suggesting something made for use rather than display.